#41 – H5N1: Why Avian Influenza Is Dangerous Again

Show notes

H5N1 avian influenza is back in the headlines, and on two fronts at once. Florian Krammer starts with the basics: why the subtype is named after its two spike proteins, hemagglutinin and neuraminidase, what separates highly pathogenic from low pathogenic strains, and why the virus still does not spread from human to human. The answer lies in the receptors, since avian strains bind alpha-2,3-linked sialic acid, which in humans is found deep in the lung but not in the upper respiratory tract. Since 1997 there have been around 900 human cases, roughly half of them fatal. Since 2020 the clade 2.3.4.4b variant has spread worldwide and shows a striking tendency to infect mammals. In 2024 it turned up unexpectedly in US dairy cattle, where it replicates in the mammary glands and spreads between cows through unsanitized milking equipment. An active outbreak in Washington State's Yakima Valley has now caused three human infections, one of them fatal, and a farm worker union reports further cases among people who avoid testing out of fear of immigration enforcement. On top of that, a mink farm outbreak in Utah has been running uncontrolled since August. The core concern: if someone is infected with seasonal flu and H5N1 at the same time, the viruses can swap genomic segments. That is exactly how the last influenza pandemics began.

Report about the cattle outbreak in Washington State: https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/avian-influenza-bird-flu/oregon-logs-its-first-h5n1-case-cows-farmer-s-union-says-human-avian-flu

Detailed report about the mink outbreak in Utah: https://www.propublica.org/article/bird-flu-mink-farm-utah-human-risk

Farm Workers Union statement about human H5N1 infections on Twitter: https://x.com/UFWupdates/status/2120328692589355089

+++++

You can support the podcast via our German Steady page: https://steady.page/virologisch/

Questions, feedback or topic suggestions? Feel free to contact us at: virological@podcastwerkstatt.com

+++++

Krammer laboratory information

Krammer Laboratory at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai https://labs.icahn.mssm.edu/krammerlab/

Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Science Outreach and Pandemic Preparedness https://soap.lbg.ac.at/

Ignaz Semmelweis Institute https://semmelweisinstitute.ac.at/

+++++

Conflict of interest statement

The Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai has filed patent applications relating to influenza virus vaccines and therapeutics, SARS-CoV-2 serological assays and NDV-based SARS-CoV-2 vaccines which name me as inventor. Mount Sinai has spun out a company, CastleVax, to commercialize NDV-based SARS-CoV-2 vaccines and I am named as co-founder and scientific advisory board member of that company.

I have previously consulted for Curevac, Merck, Gritstone, Sanofi, Seqirus, GSK and Pfizer and I am currently consulting for 3rd Rock Ventures (US) and Avimex (Mexico).

My laboratory has been collaborating in the past with Pfizer on animal models of SARS-CoV-2 and with GlaxoSmithKline and VIR on the development of influenza virus vaccines and therapeutics and we are currently collaborating with Dynavax, Inspirevax and Inimmune on development of influenza virus vaccines.

My work on immunity and infectious diseases in the US is supported by the National Institutes of Health, but also by FluLab and Tito’s Handmade Vodka. In the past I have also received funding from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, PATH and the US Department of Defense.

My work in Austria is supported by the Ludwig Boltzmann Gesellschaft and by the Ignaz Semmelweis Institute through the Medical University of Vienna.

Show transcript

00:00:05: So, the problem is once the virus acquires the ability to spread from humans to humans and we start seeing human clusters it's almost too late to counteract then like he would mean at opinioning of a new pandemic.

00:00:33: Birological with Florian Kramer.

00:00:46: Hello and welcome this week episode of Birolojical.

00:00:49: This was recorded on November sixteenths of twenty-twenty six in Vienna.

00:00:56: There have been a number of recent reports again about even influenza virus Hv and I in Kaos but also in Mink, specifically the US.

00:01:09: And they wanted to talk about that.

00:01:10: then give it some background... ...and discuss what this situation looks like right now.

00:01:17: So Hv is an influenza A-virus, a subtype of influenza A virus.

00:01:24: We know that influenza A viruses are part of the ortomixovirate family, so they're ortomixel viruses.

00:01:32: And just to explain this age five and one these letters in numbers Influenza A subtypes are named after their spike proteins.

00:01:42: there two spike proteins.

00:01:44: One is the hemagglutinin or H and That's the receptor binding protein that binds to Cialic acid.

00:01:53: And so for each five in one, that contains the subtype V imagglutinine.

00:02:01: So HV.

00:02:02: and it contains also a neuraminidase.

00:02:05: That's the second spike protein of influenza viruses... ...that is the receptor-destroying enzyme.. ..and we have type I neuraminides.

00:02:16: And this normal cage is used as seasonal influenza viruses.

00:02:23: There we have H₁N₁ circulating in humans and H₃ and II.

00:02:27: So basically, sub-tap one emigrotinine, sub tap one neuraminidase that's H₄N₂... ...and sub-taps three hemagglutinin, sub tape two neuraminides that is H₊ and II.

00:02:39: It was that easy!

00:02:41: And those subtaps for HA now go up to nineteen and four neuraminide as they go upto twelve.

00:02:48: so there are quite a few of these subtaps But today we're going to stick it to H five and one.

00:02:55: So influenza A viruses, as everybody knows are... I have a minus cent single stranded RNA genome And they have eight genomic segments.

00:03:08: so these segments basically similar to chromosomes.

00:03:13: Each of them codes for at least one protein some of them for more than one proteins.

00:03:19: One of the segments encodes for hemagglutinine, another one for neuraminidase.

00:03:25: Another one for the nuclear protein.

00:03:27: then three of them code for the polymerase subunits.

00:03:30: There's one segment that encodes matrix proteins and ion channel into ion channels And in a smaller segment it encodes non-structural proteins The nuclear export protein.

00:03:47: And in terms of the virion influenza A virus is approximately a hundred twenty nanometers in diameter.

00:03:57: They have RNA, the genomic segments.

00:04:00: on the inside these segments are protected by nuclear protein.

00:04:04: they're associated or polymerases associated with each of this segments.

00:04:10: then we have to matrix protein that sits and in that lipid membrane we have the two spike proteins, Aja and Na.

00:04:20: And then you have an ion channel M-II protein.

00:04:24: That's not just true for Hv and I it is also true of all influenza A viruses.

00:04:29: but its good to remember that they have these genomic segments.

00:04:32: We will talk about Aja as well how this plays into current situation.

00:04:38: a little bit about history on HV.

00:04:42: This sub-tip was discovered in the nineteen fifties, in Scotland.

00:04:47: And it turned out that H five and one this Mars sub-type can have two forms.

00:04:55: It could either be highly pathogenic in birds or low pathogenic In birds.

00:05:02: The hypatogenic form basically kills chickens within a few days sometimes even within two days where the low pathogenic versions cause barely any disease.

00:05:14: And, a big difference here is cleavage site in the hemagglutinin.

00:05:19: The hemaglutinine protein has to be cleaved into two parts In order get activated and only when it's activated or cleaved, the rusted caracid can be infectious.

00:05:32: If its a low-pathogenic HVN one then this cleavages of the hemaklutinin either happen in the airways by proteases, or in the GI tract.

00:05:49: And that restricts the virus to the airway and it can't go anywhere else.

00:05:56: but the highly pathogenic versions have a cleavage site which is polybasic amino acids in that cleavage site, and it means they can be recognized by furan-like broadases.

00:06:17: Furan like broadases exist every cell of the body which allows the virus to spread throughout all bodies of a bird.

00:06:26: And this makes it highly pathogenic.

00:06:28: if the virus spreads everywhere including the brain... It's clear!

00:06:32: that this virus can do a lot of damage.

00:06:35: So, that's the difference.

00:06:36: Hypatogenic avian influenza versus low-patogenic avien influenza.

00:06:41: For long time people were not concerned about HV and one when it came to humans.

00:06:47: Of course It was bad if I highly pathogenic version jumped into your chicken flock And all the chickens died.

00:06:54: That is Not Good.

00:06:56: But The idea Was It Is A Bird Virus.

00:06:58: Its Not Dangerous for Humans.

00:07:01: idea changed in nineteen ninety seven because they're the first human infections with age five and one were recorded.

00:07:09: And actually a number of people infected died, and since then there have been about nine hundred reported human cases with age-five and one and about half of them died.

00:07:21: so the virus is not as virulent in humans as in chickens but typically unfortunately pretty bad when you get infected with HVFN-one.

00:07:36: But so far, and I think that saved us from a pandemic with HvFN N-one there has been no human to human spread reported And that has to do is the hemagglutinin.

00:07:49: So in order to efficiently jump from human to Human influenza eviruses have to replicate in their upper respiratory tract.

00:08:01: I mentioned earlier that hemagglutinin is the receptor binding protein, right?

00:08:06: That binds to C-alic acid.

00:08:08: And in birds this C-Alic acid is linked to glycans via alpha two three linkage and... In the upper respiratory tract of humans, it's linked via alpha-II-VI linkage.

00:08:25: The lower respiratory tract deep in the lung... ...humans also have Cialic Acid with Alpha II-III linkage like in birds but in the Upper respiratory tract is Alpha Iii-VI.

00:08:36: And so this avian influenza viruses including HVN-I... ...too recognize Alpha II III linked Cialics acid very well But they do not.

00:08:47: Rhaecogne is alpha-to-six linked Cialic acid.

00:08:49: well, which means that in humans if you inhale this virus deep into the lung it does grow there.

00:08:56: It does a lot of damage and people might die if they get an infection but it doesn't grow well in their upper respiratory tract And that means he doesn't spread from humans to humans or typically from mammal to mammal.

00:09:10: so there's a bunch of other mammals that look similar in terms of this receptor and how it's linked as compared to humans, which can actually serve a model for transmission of influenza viruses.

00:09:26: There are other things these avian influenza viruses need so they become efficient at growing human cells.

00:09:34: The polymerase needs to adapt to the mammalian cell.

00:09:39: and then there is also some proteins we have that restrict virus growth, specifically restricts the growth of avian influenza viruses.

00:09:50: We call these proteins restriction factors.

00:09:52: one of them is the Mx protein and typically our version of the MX protein restricts avian-influenza viruses pretty well while it's pretty useless against seasonal influenza viruses.

00:10:07: they have mutated basically overcome this And the human seasonal influenza viruses bind very well to alpha-to-six link cellic acid, grow very well in our cells and are not bothered by this Mx protein.

00:10:21: So that's why they spread from human to human.

00:10:23: but again H five N one is.

00:10:26: even influenza virus has not figured it out.

00:10:28: It can when it mutates potentially But it hasn't yet... ...but basically everything that brings this virus closer to acquiring these mutations To allow for example, the hemagglutinin to bind to alpha-to-six link C-alic acid.

00:10:44: To allow the polymerase to deal better with our cells or do a lot of virus to overcome these restriction factors that we have all that brings us closer to a pandemic and this needs to be avoided right?

00:10:58: We don't want each five in one viruses where any avian influenza viruses that are spread efficiently from human to human because they could lead to an epidemic.

00:11:09: Now, each five and one has been around for some time.

00:11:11: Since nineteen ninety seven it has spread throughout the world specifically in Eurasia And Africa.

00:11:21: Sometimes there's more activity sometimes just less and In twenty-twenty a new variant of this age five and One showed up.

00:11:28: we call is now K two point three point four point four B. You don't have to remember that.

00:11:34: I'm sorry i am not The one who came out with this number cage.

00:11:38: It's actually pretty bad, but this virus showed up and it seemed that was very fit.

00:11:45: Actually can infect many different bird species including endangered birds which has caused massive diodes of different birdspecies to have threatened whole populations.

00:11:59: And also this version of the virus has a tendency to infect mammals.

00:12:07: Initially, this was mostly reported in scavengers and predators that feed on bird carcasses or would hunt birds that are weak already because they're infected.

00:12:20: And in these cases, these are foxes for example Coyotes even bears.

00:12:26: These are dead end hosts so the virus infects these animals.

00:12:29: They die but the virus doesn't spread But there has been no spread reported in marine mammals Seals, for example.

00:12:39: And then there were also reports from fur farms in Europe.

00:12:43: For example In Spain the virus made it into a mink farm and started to spread Therefrom mink-to-mink and in Finland It made it Into fur farms as well and spread their from foxes From Fox To Fox.

00:12:57: Those are dangerous situations because when this happens The virus can mutate mutated in a way that makes it better to infect these animals, this mammals and It makes you better to grow in these mammalian cells.

00:13:11: And That means like here also can't grow bad in humans?

00:13:16: And that brings us closer to the scenario where we can spread from humans to humans.

00:13:20: so The way people responded in Spain and Finland today was too depopulate.

00:13:26: these farms sounds technical but basically once they were started to spread their tip basically had to kill all these animals, To make sure that the virus couldn't spread and could mutate.

00:13:37: This new version of the virus has so far now spread throughout the world not just Eurasia in Africa but it also made into the Americas.

00:13:47: It's even found in Antarctica In Australia And so on.

00:13:52: That is possible through migratory birds.

00:13:55: So many birds.

00:13:57: this virus is highly lethal and kills them very quickly.

00:14:01: But then there's other bird species like mallard dogs that are infected, but they don't get sick.

00:14:07: And this spread the virus and... That what spreads it?

00:14:10: This birds spread throughout the globe!

00:14:13: An HVN-I virus spreads through birds is not very surprising in that sometimes mammals get infected.

00:14:20: specifically when defeat on carcasses of birds who have succumbed to infection with HVM-I is also not so surprising.

00:14:30: but something very surprising happened in twenty-twenty four.

00:14:34: So avian influenza viruses and influenza A virus is, In general are not known to infect cows.

00:14:42: But in Twenty-Twenty Four there were reports from Texas initially... ...but then also other states like Idaho or Ohio, Michigan New Mexico and so on.

00:14:53: that H five and one this avian Influencer Virus was infecting cows dairy cattle and dairy farms.

00:15:03: That was super surprising!

00:15:05: And the virus started to spread in these animals, it actually started spreading from farm-to-farm through transport of animals... ...and again this was super suprising.

00:15:18: initially everybody was scratching their head to figure out how that had happened.

00:15:23: It's also still not clear how the virus got into this dairy cattle.

00:15:27: probably some interaction with infected birds.

00:15:32: And actually, when you look at these H-V and I viruses that circulate in North America they can be classified into different genotypes.

00:15:41: so we have this clad, it's already complicated name is clad two point three point four point four B but then depending on the genomic segments that these virus has because they acquired new genomic segment through reassortment from.

00:15:58: you can also genotype them.

00:16:00: And so the first genotype that was found in this dairy cattle, was Genotype B-III-III but then also Genotype D-I was found.

00:16:11: there were multiple introductions into dairy cattle and interesting part here is that this virus isn't necessarily causing respiratory infections.

00:16:23: it's actually infecting memory cans or other.

00:16:29: The viruses secreted through milk, there's actually tons of virus in the milk of this infected cows.

00:16:35: They do get sick.

00:16:36: they don't necessarily die from infection.

00:16:39: most of these cows recover but basically their milk production during the infection goes down quite a bit and... ...the interesting thing also is that cows in their memory glands have cells that both receptors, the avian receptor alpha-II-III linkceolic acid human receptor alpha-to-six link C-alic acid.

00:17:02: And so, the idea is that the virus they are still using this Alpha-to three linked C-Alic Acid and doesn't necessarily have to bind to Alpha six Link C-Alic Acid which is good because if the virus would have to switch to Alpha two six mutate then it will be again more dangerous for humans.

00:17:20: It turned out that the viruses spreading often through milking equipment That's not properly sanitized between milking into different cows And as I said, there are high titers of virus in the milk of this infected cows.

00:17:38: Actually if cats for example on these farms drink their milk from infected cows they often get infected and die.

00:17:46: that's also how mice got infected on dairy cattle farms and the virus can spread back from these cows actually into birds.

00:17:57: This has happened also helps the virus spread again.

00:18:02: For humans, that's less dangerous because milk for human consumption is usually pasteurized and it means that the virus is killed.

00:18:12: you can still find a genome of the virus in pasteurised milk but its not infectious anymore.

00:18:16: so thats good.

00:18:20: So this happened repeatedly in the United States.

00:18:24: These outbreaks are still ongoing, we'll get to that in a second.

00:18:28: I just wanted to point out this not only happened in the United States but also happening in the Netherlands.

00:18:34: There was report on January of the fall of the Dutch dairy farm in Friesland where a cat died died of age five and one.

00:18:45: And then there was an investigation, it turned out that a number of cows on this farm actually were zero positive so had antibodies for each five-and-one That looked like they have been previously infected.

00:18:58: One of the cows was reportedly sick few weeks earlier.

00:19:03: The farmer has already also reported that There are dead birds in the meadows.

00:19:11: might have been a source of infection for these cows.

00:19:15: However, in the Netherlands this did not spread to state on one farm.

00:19:20: there was no further spread through other farms.

00:19:23: so it's important that Canada is monitoring their cows and milk production.

00:19:32: for two years now they've also not found the virus in their cow farms.

00:19:39: But in the US this spread and this probably has to do how agriculture works there.

00:19:45: Large companies run some of these dairy farms, they move cows around from one state to another.

00:19:51: that contributed to their spread And This was not stopped back then in twenty-twenty four by the Biden administration.

00:19:59: The current government is also doing much about it.

00:20:05: It has been shown that vaccines can be used to stop the spread between cows, so you can vaccinate these cows against age five and one.

00:20:13: This is not something that's currently done in the US although it would very useful if we could do this.

00:20:22: But again...this brings us back into this problem.

00:20:24: when the virus grows a lot then jumps from mammal-to-mammal can actually mutate or get better at infecting mammals transmitting from mammal to mammal and that makes it more dangerous for humans.

00:20:41: And of course, humans also come in contact with these cows because on farms people partially milked this cows, partially they just feed them and care for them right?

00:20:52: But there is interaction!

00:20:54: This has already led a number of human infections.

00:20:59: the majority were actually mild.

00:21:02: some included respiratory symptoms Others included connectivitis, so basically infection in the eye.

00:21:11: And humans in their eyes actually have this alpha-II-III linked cellic acid.

00:21:15: So that's the right receptor for the virus.

00:21:18: and these eye infections often happen when people milk cows There is some milk that is squirting into their eye.

00:21:26: then they get these infections.

00:21:30: But of course human infections also carry the risk to further mutate.

00:21:36: As I said, most of them so far were mild but this changed now a little bit.

00:21:42: There's another risk here and that is reassortment.

00:21:46: So i told you earlier that these influenza viruses have these H-genomic segments And they are like chromosomes right?

00:21:56: And like chromosomes these genomic segments can be exchanged between viruses.

00:22:02: in fact the same cell is always that a human might be infected with human influenza virus, human seasonal influenza virus H-one N-one or H-three and two.

00:22:15: And then there's the co-infection within each five N one influenza virus for example from a cow.

00:22:24: If it happens in the same cells are infected The H-V and one, the H-one N-one or H three two seasonal influenza virus.

00:22:32: they can exchange genomic segments.

00:22:34: And then there can be a new virus that now maybe has H five in one spikes on the surface but it has to replication machinery from a seasonal influenza.

00:22:45: was this already highly adapted to humans?

00:22:48: That would be huge.

00:22:49: issue is actually how last few influenza pandemics have started with these reassortments.

00:22:58: And this is what at least influencer researchers are worried about, that this might happen.

00:23:06: it's a fast track for the better to humans and risk of course higher in winter season right when there're lot seasonal influencers circulating in human.

00:23:19: so this something people really worry about.

00:23:25: current outbreak, as I said this virus has jumped into chaos in twenty-twenty four and have been in dairy cattle since then.

00:23:35: But the last few months there was actually fewer activity.

00:23:39: it looked like.

00:23:40: you know infections are going down a little bit even though over time more than thousand farms had been affected probably more.

00:23:49: but in some states They also don't find these infections specifically if they don't look on purpose and looked the other way.

00:24:01: But there is now a very active outbreak in Washington state, in Yakima Valley And this has already spread to Dairy Captain Oregon and Idaho.

00:24:14: This current outbreak has already caused three human cases.

00:24:22: All of those were through exposure to cattle.

00:24:25: So it's not like people got infected through a contact with another infected human.

00:24:32: It was all in contact to cattle.

00:24:34: Two of those infections were relatively mild.

00:24:37: Unfortunately one of them caused the person to die.

00:24:43: This was a person who is underlying conditions.

00:24:46: Yeah, well unfortunately passed away from after getting infected and that's already bad enough.

00:24:54: But recently there was a report from the Farm Work Union, basically this came out on November eleventh that they actually know of number people who have been infected but haven't officially reported it.

00:25:12: Basically people working in these dairy farms were afraid to speak their authorities.

00:25:17: There has been recent activity with ICE agents and migration enforcement in this region.

00:25:25: And so it seems that there are infected people who were really worried about disclosing they're infected and talking to the authorities, which is of course bad!

00:25:38: It's not clear because these aren't official cases or if those people have been tested for HVN-I infections due to contact with infected cows or if it's seasonal influenza, and that is the other problem.

00:25:51: There are currently a lot of seasonal influenza activity specifically H-one N-one in the United States And this also increases risk again That people get these co-infections between seasonal influenza and H-five N one.

00:26:06: They then lead to reassortment and potentially lead to new pandemic.

00:26:11: So right now doesn't look like this situation is really under control.

00:26:17: It would be time for authorities to step in and start cutting down on these outbreaks, either through vaccination or more stringent regulations in terms of transporting cattle.

00:26:32: But then there's another situations that are also relatively dangerous because it could lead to mutations.

00:26:41: that allows it to better spread from human-to-human.

00:26:45: So there's an active outbreak currently on a mink farm in Utah, so again this is a fur farm and the first detection of HVFN one from August, twenty-twenty six.

00:27:01: I think samples were submitted also for sequencing and it turned out this is the same B three thirteen genotype that was found in Dairy cattle.

00:27:10: so somehow these virus made potentially from cows to mink farm could have been through birds in between.

00:27:19: It's not really clear how this animals got infected but the virus started spreading on this mink farms And in contrast to what happened in Europe, where then these farms were affected or depopulated.

00:27:34: To make sure that the virus can't adapt to mammalian hosts and become more dangerous to humans this outbreak is still ongoing.

00:27:43: There's a pro-public article about it That yeah at end of October The outbreak was still uncontrolled.

00:27:51: They basically kid is infected animals in that facility and the virus continues to spread from animal-to-animal.

00:27:59: And of course, it's also hugely concerning because mink like ferrets and other similar animals actually have a human receptor in their upper respiratory tract, this alpha two six link zealic acid... ...and so it would be really time to shut outbreaks like that down or minimize risk.

00:28:18: these viruses change, mutate, resort and then start another pandemic.

00:28:25: That's it for today!

00:28:27: Yeah concerning situation both in Washington state as well as in Utah let's hope that this gets under control relatively quickly.

00:28:37: on the other side is the situation in the dairy.

00:28:40: cattle farms are out of hand quite some time now and it also has not been stopped.

00:28:51: So we can just hope for the best, The problem is once the virus acquires the ability to spread from humans to humans And when you start seeing human clusters with human-to-human transmission It's almost too late to counteract that then likely would mean the beginning of a new pandemic.

00:29:13: Let us hope this will not happen but certainly in situation needs to be monitored.

00:29:18: So that's it for today.

00:29:20: Thanks for listening!

00:29:21: As always, if you have any comments questions or concerns please just write an email to our Virological at podcastwerkstatt.com and If you like the podcast feel free to support us on steady.

00:29:35: thanks a lot And until next time Bye And don't forget to follow and leave a review on your favorite podcast app.

00:30:13: Podcastwerkstatt!

New comment

Your name or nickname, will be shown publicly
At least 10 characters long
By submitting your comment you agree that the content of the field "Name or nickname" will be stored and shown publicly next to your comment. Using your real name is optional.